Disclaimer: This article contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support and maintain the operation of this blog, allowing me to continue providing valuable content and recommendations. Rest assured that I only recommend products and brands that I personally use and trust. Your support through these affiliate links is greatly appreciated and helps keep this blog running. Thank you for your support!
Introduction
If you’re reading this, then like me, you are now on the journey I once was. Which is better? A sling vs backpack for travel. For years I had carried around my backpack, and more and more, I’ve seen people all over wearing slings. Their rise in popularity alone is a reason to check them out, but now that I’ve done a few trips with both, I’m confident in my position on the topic. In this post, I’ll breakdown what I like, don’t like, and where I ended up.
Table of Contents
Travel Backpacks
Pros of Travel Backpacks
- Storage Capacity: Travel backpacks generally offer ample storage space. They come in various sizes, from compact daypacks to larger backpacks suitable for extended trips. This versatility allows you to pack everything you need, whether you’re going on a weekend getaway or a month-long adventure.
- Organizational Features: Many travel backpacks, like the Travelon Anti-Theft Classic Large Backpack (our favorite), are designed with multiple compartments, pockets, and sleeves, making it easier to keep your belongings organized and accessible. This anti-theft backpack also provides added security, giving you peace of mind during your travels.
- Comfort and Support: Good-quality travel backpacks are equipped with padded shoulder straps, adjustable waist belts, and breathable back panels, ensuring a comfortable and ergonomic fit during long hours of exploration or hiking.
- Security: Most travel backpacks have anti-theft features, such as lockable zippers and RFID-blocking pockets, to help keep your belongings secure in crowded places. Look for a bag that is slash proof! It’s common for thieves to try to cut open the bag to quickly get to its contents. This was a big selling point for the Travelon bag that we use.
- Rainy Days: On rainy days, a backpack like the Travelon Anti-Theft Classic is perfect for carrying packable rain jackets and umbrellas. Its spacious design ensures that your belongings stay dry while you navigate through wet weather.
- Personal Experience: I personally use the Travelon Anti-Theft Classic Large Backpack on every trip, and it proves invaluable for carrying my camera, ipad and electronics. Remarkably, I purchased this backpack six years ago, and it’s still in perfect shape. I also use it every day for work, and it has held up through years of carrying my 16” laptop and all of my work supplies.
Cons of Travel Backpacks
- Bulkiness: Larger travel backpacks can be bulky and heavy when fully loaded. This might not be ideal if you prefer to travel light or have limited physical strength.
- Accessibility: Accessing items at the bottom of your backpack can be challenging, requiring you to unpack and repack frequently.
Travel Slings
Pros of Travel Slings
- Compactness: Travel slings are incredibly compact and lightweight, making them perfect for minimalist travelers or those who want to move swiftly through crowded streets and public transportation.
- Quick Access: With a travel sling like the Moment MTW 2-liter sling, you can access your essentials quickly and easily due to their single-strap design. This is advantageous when you need to retrieve your passport, camera (like the Fujifilm XT3), or snacks on the go.
- Style: Travel slings often have a sleek and stylish design, making them a fashionable accessory to complement your travel attire.
- Versatility: Travel slings can double as daypacks, camera bags, or even gym bags, offering versatile functionality.
- Sunny Days: On sunny days when you plan to be walking around all day, the sling is a better choice for less weight on your back, with the added security of keeping your belongings on your chest. This is especially convenient for those who want to capture spontaneous moments with their camera.
- Personal Experience: I’ve personally used the Moment MTW 2-liter sling for sunny day explorations, and its lightweight design and quick-access pockets made it an excellent choice for carrying my camera, a Fujifilm XT3. It fits snugly with the 23mm f2 lens attached, and one extra lens, room for a few extra batteries, my slim wallet, and my sunglasses. However, with everything in it, the bag is truly at maximum capacity. I found myself wishing for a slightly larger bag, or a slightly smaller camera like the Fujifilm x100iv. Perhaps a 3-liter version, which would likely be perfect for accommodating all my essentials without feeling cramped.
Cons of Travel Slings
- Limited Storage: Travel slings have a smaller storage capacity compared to backpacks, which can be restricting if you need to carry more than just the essentials.
- Comfort for Extended Use: While comfortable for short outings, travel slings may become uncomfortable if worn for extended periods, especially when loaded with heavy items. Keeping your load under 5 lbs is recommended if you plan to wear all day.
- Security: They may be more susceptible to theft since they’re easier to grab and run with if you take it off compared to backpacks.
Conclusion
In the debate of travel backpacks vs. travel slings, it’s clear that each has its own unique advantages and disadvantages, making them valuable tools for different aspects of your travel experience. If you can only have one, I’d recommend a travel backpack due to its versatility. That being said, since having and experiencing both, I’m not leaving either one at home.
I recommend having both a travel backpack and a travel sling in your travel arsenal. Why limit yourself when you can enjoy the benefits of both? They each shine in specific situations during your journey.
A Travel Backpack: Ideal for longer journeys and adventures where ample storage, organization, and comfort are essential. Use it when you need to carry a variety of items, from clothing to electronics. The anti-theft features, like lockable zippers and RFID-blocking pockets, provide added security in crowded places. And on rainy days, your backpack can comfortably carry your packable rain jackets and umbrellas.
A Travel Sling: Perfect for sunny days when you plan to be on your feet, exploring all day. The compact and lightweight design reduces the weight on your back while providing quick access to your essentials, such as your camera, passport, wallet, and sunglasses. It’s the go-to choice when you want to capture spontaneous moments while keeping your belongings close and secure on your chest.
Incorporating both a travel backpack and a travel sling into your travel gear collection ensures that you’re prepared for every situation, enhancing your travel experience and making each adventure a memorable one. So, why choose between them when you can have the best of both worlds? Pick the bag that suits the moment, and embark on your next journey with confidence!
Our Top Recommendations
Our Backpack Pick
Travelon Anti-Theft Classic Large Backpack – As mentioned earlier, this backpack is a reliable choice with ample storage and anti-theft features. It’s perfect for those who prioritize security and organization.
Other Backpack Options
Osprey Farpoint 40 Travel Backpack – Osprey is known for its comfortable and well-designed backpacks. The Farpoint 40 offers a versatile size that’s suitable for both short trips and longer adventures.
North Face Recon Backpack – If you’re after durability and versatility, the North Face Recon Backpack is a popular option. It’s designed for both outdoor adventures and everyday use, making it a great choice for those who need a dependable all-rounder.
Bonus Backpack Suggestion
We love these Colombia Packable Backpacks! If we plan to do shopping or want the ability to expand our storage easily, we keep one or two of these in our backpack. They pack down into the size of about a quart sized sandwich bag and fold out into a 22L backpack! When we aren’t planning on carrying valuables, or just want a super light bag to bring with us, the Colombia Packable Backpack is our go to!
Our Sling Pick
Moment MTW 2-Liter Sling – As previously mentioned, the Moment MTW Sling is a stylish and functional choice. It’s perfect for sunny day explorations and quick access to your essentials.
Other Sling Options
Peak Design Everyday Sling – 3L – Peak Design is renowned for its camera gear, and their Everyday Sling lives up to their reputation. It’s designed with photographers in mind but works well for anyone who wants a sleek and versatile sling. I would have gone with this sling, but I liked the look of the Moment MTW a little more.
Patagonia Atom Sling 8L – Patagonia’s Atom Sling is a compact and eco-friendly option for those who appreciate sustainable materials. It’s great for day trips and urban adventures. It’s large size makes it a true hybrid between a backpack and a sling. If you only want to bring one on your trip, this might be the best option.
Travelon Greenlander Sustainable Anti-Theft Small Crossbody – For eco-conscious travelers, the this travel sling is an excellent choice. It combines sustainability with anti-theft features, making it a responsible and secure option for your travels. This is the smallest of all of our recommendations, so if you’re just looking to carry your phone, passport, wallet and glasses, this is a great compact pick.
With these additional recommendations, you have a wider range of choices to suit your specific travel needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize security, organization, durability, or style, there’s a travel backpack or sling out there that’s perfect for your next adventure. Happy travels!
